Left-handedness, a trait present in about 10% of the global population, has long intrigued scientists. One popular but oversimplified hypothesis claims that many left-handed individuals are survivors of a vanished twin absorbed in the womb—a phenomenon called vanishing twin syndrome (VTS). While VTS is a real and relatively common occurrence, it does not fully explain why people are left-handed, nor does it mean that most left-handers “ate” their twins. Here’s what science actually tells us.
What Is Vanishing Twin Syndrome and How Common Is It?
Vanishing twin syndrome happens when one fetus in a multiple pregnancy dies early—usually in the first trimester—and is partially or completely absorbed by the surviving twin or the mother’s body. This process often goes unnoticed because it occurs before many women even realize they are carrying multiples.
– Prevalence:
Studies estimate that VTS occurs in 15% to 35% of twin pregnancies detected by early ultrasound scans, and in about 50% of pregnancies with three or more gestational sacs. The wide range depends on detection methods and timing of ultrasounds. (Sources: StatPearls, PubMed 2022, London Pregnancy Clinic 2025
– Detection:
VTS is usually confirmed by early ultrasound scans showing multiple gestational sacs or heartbeats, followed by later scans showing only one viable fetus. Sometimes remnants of the vanished twin are visible, but often the tissue is fully absorbed. Blood tests measuring pregnancy hormones (hCG) may also provide clues.
How Does Left-Handedness Develop?
Handedness is a complex trait influenced by genetics, prenatal environment, brain development, and random factors.
– Genetics:
Genetic factors account for about 25% of the variance in handedness. Several genes have been linked to handedness, but no single gene determines it.
– Prenatal Environment:
Factors such as prenatal hormone exposure (e.g., testosterone levels), birth stress, and fetal position can influence brain lateralization—the division of functions between the left and right hemispheres—which in turn affects hand preference.
– Developmental Timing:
Handedness begins to emerge prenatally, as early as the first trimester, when the brain’s hemispheres start to specialize. By the second trimester, fetal movements show a preference for one hand.
– Random Variation:
Some degree of randomness in brain development also contributes to handedness.
Does Vanishing Twin Syndrome Cause Left-Handedness?
While VTS can affect prenatal development, the evidence does not support it as a primary cause of left-handedness:
– Twins vs. Vanished Twins:
Twins have a slightly higher rate of left-handedness (~17%) than singletons (~10%), but most twins do not experience VTS. Therefore, increased left-handedness in twins cannot be solely attributed to absorbing a vanished twin.
– Singletons with Vanished Twins:
Many individuals who survived a vanished twin pregnancy are right-handed. There is no conclusive data showing that absorbing a twin flips handedness.
– Complex Causes:
Handedness is influenced by many factors; VTS may be one minor environmental factor but cannot explain the majority of left-handedness cases.
How Is Vanishing Twin Syndrome Confirmed?
– Ultrasound Imaging:
Early pregnancy ultrasounds can detect multiple gestational sacs or heartbeats. Follow-up ultrasounds showing a reduction to a single viable fetus indicate VTS.
– Hormonal Markers:
Abnormal patterns in pregnancy hormone levels (e.g., hCG) may suggest early loss of a twin.
– Placental Examination:
In rare cases, examination of the placenta after birth can reveal evidence of a vanished twin.
– Genetic Testing:
Advanced genetic and epigenetic tests can sometimes detect mosaicism or chimerism resulting from twin absorption, but these are not routine.
Summary
– Vanishing twin syndrome is relatively common in early twin pregnancies but does not occur in most pregnancies overall.
– Left-handedness is a multifactorial trait influenced by genetics, prenatal environment, brain development, and chance.
– There is no strong scientific evidence that absorbing a twin causes left-handedness.
– Many twins who do not experience VTS are left-handed, and many singletons who survived a vanished twin are right-handed.
– Diagnosing VTS relies primarily on early ultrasound imaging and sometimes hormonal or placental evidence.
Understanding handedness requires recognizing its complex origins rather than attributing it to a single cause like vanishing twin syndrome.
Sources:
– Linoy Batsry & Yoav Yinon, “The Vanishing Twin: Diagnosis and Implications,” Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol, 2022.
– London Pregnancy Clinic, “Vanishing Twin Syndrome,” 2025.
– WebMD, “Vanishing Twins,” 2023.
– StatPearls, “Vanishing Twin Syndrome,” 2023.
– Medland et al., “Handedness in Twins,” Twin Research and Human Genetics, 2009.
– NIH Genetics Home Reference on Handedness.
Read More
[1] https://www.obgproject.com/2018/06/10/vanishing-twin-pregnancy-outcomes-ivf-icsi-vs-natural-conception/
[2] https://www.londonpregnancy.com/vanishing-twin-syndrome/
[3] https://www.webmd.com/baby/what-is-a-vanishing-twin
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanishing_twin
[5] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35450773/
[6] https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/endocrinology/articles/10.3389/fendo.2022.832665/full
[7] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1521693422000487
[8] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK563220/