Contrary to popular belief, dark mode does not universally reduce eye strain. Research indicates that for some individuals, particularly those with astigmatism or myopia, dark mode can exacerbate eye strain. This is because the reduced brightness may cause the pupils to dilate, making it harder to focus on the text and potentially leading to symptoms such as headaches and visual fatigue

For Web Sites, Is White Text on a Black Background Better for Eyes?

The debate over whether white text on a black background is better for eye health compared to traditional black text on a white background has gained significant attention in recent years. This discussion is particularly relevant as dark mode interfaces become increasingly popular in digital applications and websites. Understanding the implications of these color schemes on visual comfort and eye strain is essential for both users and designers.

The Science Behind Color Contrast

Visual Acuity and Color Sensitivity

Research indicates that the contrast polarity—whether text is light on dark or dark on light—affects visual acuity. A study found that reading black text on a white background overstimulates the OFF ganglion cells in the retina, potentially leading to myopia (nearsightedness) over time. Conversely, white text on a black background stimulates the ON ganglion cells, which may inhibit myopia development.

The claim that reading black text on a white background overstimulates the OFF ganglion cells in the retina, potentially leading to myopia, while white text on a black background stimulates the ON ganglion cells and may inhibit myopia development, requires careful examination based on available research.

1. Contrast Polarity and Visual Resolution: Research indicates that the contrast polarity of text (light on dark vs. dark on light) does affect visual resolution. A study published in 2022 assessed how color and polarity influence visual resolution with varying contrast ratios. It found that visual resolution significantly varied with different text-background combinations, suggesting that black text on a white background generally provides better clarity compared to white text on a black background, particularly at lower contrast levels[2].

2. Myopia Development: There is some evidence suggesting that reading black text on a white background may contribute to myopia development. A specific study noted that the choroid (the vascular layer of the eye) became thinner when subjects read black text on a white background, while it thickened when reading white text on a black background. This finding implies that using dark mode might have some potential to inhibit myopia progression, but more research is needed to fully understand these mechanisms[2][3].

3. Neural Responses: The claim regarding the stimulation of ON and OFF ganglion cells is based on the understanding of how different types of ganglion cells respond to light stimuli. However, while there is some theoretical basis for this distinction, empirical evidence directly linking these responses to long-term visual health outcomes like myopia is still limited. Most existing studies focus on broader aspects of visual acuity and color sensitivity rather than specific neural pathways in relation to text color polarity[1][4].

While there are studies indicating that contrast polarity can influence visual acuity and potentially myopia development, the relationship is complex and not fully understood. The assertion that white text on a black background universally inhibits myopia while black text on a white background promotes it lacks comprehensive empirical support at this time. Further research is necessary to clarify these relationships and their implications for visual health.

Eye Strain and Comfort

Pure black backgrounds can cause visual discomfort due to their lack of emitted light, forcing the eyes to work harder to absorb information. This phenomenon can lead to “halation,” where the bright text appears to bleed into the dark background, especially problematic for individuals with astigmatism. Studies suggest that using a dark gray background instead of pure black can mitigate these issues by allowing some light emission, thus reducing eye strain and improving reading stamina.

Dark Mode vs. Light Mode: User Experience

Preferences in Different Environments

User preferences for dark mode often stem from perceived comfort in low-light conditions. In dim environments, dark mode may reduce glare and make reading less jarring. However, in well-lit settings, dark mode can force the eyes to dilate more, which may increase strain as they struggle to focus on lighter text against a dark backdrop.

Impact on Reading Performance

Contrary to popular belief, research has shown that reading performance tends to be better with black text on a white background due to the natural constriction of pupils in response to bright backgrounds, enhancing clarity and focus. A study demonstrated that participants performed better in tasks requiring visual acuity when using positive polarity (black text on white) compared to negative polarity (white text on black).

Health Implications of Long-Term Use

Myopia Development

The long-term implications of using different text-background combinations are significant. The aforementioned studies suggest that prolonged exposure to black text on white backgrounds could lead to choroidal thinning, while reading white text on black backgrounds might promote choroidal thickening, which is associated with reduced myopia risk.

Accessibility Concerns

Accessibility remains a crucial factor in this discussion. Individuals with certain visual impairments, such as astigmatism or photophobia, may find reading white text on a black background particularly challenging due to increased glare and difficulty focusing. This emphasizes the need for designers to consider user diversity when implementing color schemes.

Conclusion

The choice between white text on a black background versus black text on a white background involves multiple factors including visual comfort, readability, and long-term eye health. While dark mode offers aesthetic appeal and potential benefits in low-light conditions, it may not universally enhance eye comfort or performance. Ultimately, user preference plays a significant role; providing options for users to select their preferred contrast settings could be the best approach for accommodating diverse needs and improving overall experience.

Future research should continue exploring these dynamics as technology evolves and user interfaces become more sophisticated.

It will take quite some time to convert this site into a non-dark mode web site. Okay, did that.

Read More
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20378093/
[2] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9185210/
[3] https://journals.lww.com/annals-of-medicine-and-surgery/fulltext/2024/02000/correlation_between_color_vision,_visual_acuity,.17.aspx
[4] https://www.olympus-lifescience.com/de/microscope-resource/primer/lightandcolor/humanvisionintro/
[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Visual_acuity
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_vision
[7] https://www.webmd.com/eye-health/contrast-sensitivity-issues-with-vision
[8] https://www.vectorvision.com/contrast-sensitivity-background/